The numbers / Explainer

Overlapping groups can make a combined percentage exceed the whole

Category percentages cannot always be added because the same person, event or item may belong to more than one group.

By Breaking Click · Published November 21, 2026 · 3 min read

Two translucent data circles overlapping with repeated tokens highlighted in the shared area
Breaking Click editorial illustration.

Percentages add neatly only when categories are mutually exclusive and use the same denominator. If one person can belong to several groups, adding the shares counts some people more than once.

A survey may report the percentage who use one service and the percentage who use another. People who use both appear in each figure, so the two percentages can total more than 100 percent without any calculation error.

Look for phrases such as select all that apply, multiple responses allowed or categories overlap. If the note is missing, ask whether membership in one category prevents membership in another.

To find the share in either of two groups, the overlap must be subtracted once after adding the separate shares. A simple overlap diagram or cross-tabulation can make that relationship visible.

Writers should identify the denominator and state when categories are nonexclusive. Readers should not treat a total above 100 percent as automatically suspicious until they know how the groups were defined.

Continue reading